GPS Collar vs E-Collar: What’s the Difference for Hunting Dogs?

New hunting dog owners often hear the terms GPS collar and e-collar used interchangeably. While some modern systems combine both, GPS collars and e-collars serve very different purposes.

Understanding the difference is important—especially for wide-ranging breeds like German Shorthaired Pointers.

What Is an E-Collar?

An e-collar is a training tool. It’s designed to help reinforce commands such as recall, whoa, or stop.

Most e-collars offer:

• Tone
• Vibration
• Stimulation at adjustable levels

Used correctly, an e-collar helps improve communication between handler and dog, especially at a distance.

What Is a GPS Collar?

A GPS collar is a tracking and safety tool.

Its primary job is to tell you:

• Where your dog is
• How far they’ve ranged
• Whether they’re moving or standing still

For hunting dogs that cover large ground, GPS collars provide information that training alone cannot.

The Key Difference (Simple Explanation)

• An e-collar helps you communicate
• A GPS collar helps you locate

One corrects behavior.
The other prevents losing your dog.

They solve different problems.

Do Hunting Dogs Need Both?

For many hunters, the answer is yes.

German Shorthaired Pointers in particular:

• Range far naturally
• Work independently
• Can disappear quickly in heavy cover

A combined GPS and training system allows you to:

• Reinforce commands
• Monitor location
• Recover your dog quickly if needed

Can One Replace the Other?

No.

An e-collar cannot tell you where your dog is if they disappear over a ridge.
A GPS collar cannot teach obedience on its own.

They work best together, especially for upland hunters and serious trainers.

Which Should You Buy First?

That depends on how you use your dog.

• If your dog already has basic obedience but ranges far, start with a GPS collar
• If you’re focused on training close-range control, start with an e-collar
• If you hunt regularly, a combined GPS and training system is often the best long-term solution

Final Thoughts

GPS collars and e-collars are not interchangeable. Each serves a distinct role, and understanding the difference helps you choose the right tool for your dog and hunting style.

For a breakdown of specific systems that work well for German Shorthaired Pointers, see our guide to the best GPS collars for German Shorthaired Pointers and our recommendations for e-collars for hunting dogs.

Also check out our recommendations for GPS collars where cell service is unavailable here.

Disclosure

This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.