GPS collars and e-collars are often confused, but they serve very different purposes. Many German Shorthaired Pointer owners end up buying the wrong system simply because they don’t understand what each one actually does.
This guide explains the difference clearly — and helps you decide which one you actually need.
What a GPS Collar Does
A GPS collar tracks your dog’s location in real time. It allows you to see:
- Distance from you
- Direction of travel
- Speed and movement
- Whether the dog is on point or moving
GPS collars are primarily used for:
- Upland hunting
- Large properties
- Off-leash work
- Safety and recovery
A GPS collar does not correct behavior. It only shows where the dog is.
What an E-Collar Does
An e-collar is a training and communication tool. It allows you to reinforce commands at a distance using:
- Tone
- Vibrate
- Stimulation
E-collars are used for:
- Recall
- Whoa training
- Boundary enforcement
- Safety corrections
An e-collar does not track location.
Why Many GSP Owners Need Both
German Shorthaired Pointers are:
- Fast
- Independent
- High-drive
Because of this, many owners eventually use both systems together:
- GPS for location and awareness
- E-collar for control and communication
This combination provides both safety and reliability in the field.
Combo Systems: GPS + E-Collar
Some systems combine GPS tracking and e-collar functionality into one unit.
Advantages:
- One collar
- One handheld
- Less gear
Disadvantages:
- Higher cost
- More complex setup
- Overkill for some owners
For serious hunters, combo systems are often worth it.
When You Only Need a GPS Collar
A GPS collar alone may be enough if:
- Your dog is already highly trained
- You hunt large areas
- Control is not an issue
- Your main concern is location
Many experienced handlers rely heavily on GPS once training is solid.
When You Only Need an E-Collar
An e-collar alone may be enough if:
- Training is the primary focus
- Work is done closer range
- You don’t hunt large tracts of land
This is common for early training phases.
Common Mistake: Expecting One Tool to Do Everything
No single collar does everything perfectly.
Problems occur when owners expect:
- GPS to replace training
- E-collars to provide location
- One tool to fix all behavior
Understanding the role of each tool prevents frustration.
Final Thoughts
GPS collars and e-collars solve different problems. For many German Shorthaired Pointer owners, the best setup eventually includes both — whether as separate devices or a combined system.
The right choice depends on how and where you hunt, not just what’s popular.
Disclosure
This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
We publish field-tested gear reviews, training guidance, and safety resources specifically for German Shorthaired Pointer owners who hunt, train, and live with their dogs year-round.