Dogtra 1900X vs ARC-X: Which E-Collar Is Better for Your German Shorthaired Pointer? (2026)
Last Updated: June 2026
If you’ve narrowed your search to the Dogtra 1900X and the Dogtra ARC-X, you’re already looking at two of the best e-collars available for German Shorthaired Pointers.
The difficult part is deciding which one fits your dog and hunting style.
Both collars offer outstanding reliability, smooth stimulation, and waterproof construction, but they were designed for slightly different users.
In this comparison, I’ll explain where each collar shines and help you choose the best option for your GSP.
💲 Save 5% on qualifying Dogtra orders over $199 with coupon code: GSP5
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Dogtra 1900X | Dogtra ARC-X |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Hunting & Field Work | Everyday Training + Hunting |
| Range | ¾ Mile | ¾ Mile |
| Receiver Size | Larger | Slimmer |
| Waterproof | ✔ | ✔ |
| Rechargeable | ✔ | ✔ |
| Tone / Vibration | ✔ | ✔ |
| My Rating | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
At a Glance
Choose the Dogtra 1900X if:
Your GSP is primarily a hunting dog
You train hard several times a week
Your dog regularly covers long distances
You want Dogtra’s flagship training collar
Choose the ARC-X if:
Your dog wears the collar frequently
Comfort is important
You split time between hunting and family life
You want a lower-profile receiver
Receiver Size
This is the biggest difference.
Dogtra 1900X
The 1900X has a larger receiver built for serious hunting environments.
It’s extremely durable and feels nearly indestructible.
For dedicated bird dogs, that’s a major advantage.
ARC-X
The ARC-X receiver is noticeably slimmer.
Many owners find it more comfortable for all-day wear.
If your dog wears a collar during walks, hikes, obedience training, and weekends in the field, the ARC-X is hard to beat.
Winner
ARC-X
Hunting Performance
Both collars perform exceptionally well.
The difference is how they’re typically used.
Dogtra 1900X
Built with hunting in mind.
Perfect for:
- Pheasants
- Grouse
- Woodcock
- Quail
- Waterfowl training
Its rugged construction inspires confidence when conditions get rough.
ARC-X
Also performs very well in the field.
Its slimmer receiver simply makes it more comfortable between hunts.
Winner
Slight edge to the 1900X
Everyday Training
If your GSP spends more time training than hunting, this category becomes important.
The ARC-X almost disappears on the dog’s neck.
That makes it an excellent collar for:
- Recall
- Heel
- Hiking
- Off-leash walks
- Daily obedience
Winner
ARC-X
Ease of Use
Both transmitters are excellent.
Large buttons.
Easy controls.
Quick adjustments.
No complicated menus.
Winner
Tie
Battery Life
Both collars feature fast charging and excellent battery life.
Most owners will never notice a meaningful difference.
Winner
Tie
Waterproof Design
German Shorthaired Pointers love water.
Fortunately, both collars are completely waterproof.
Whether you’re crossing creeks, hunting in rain, or training in wet grass, either collar is built for the job.
Winner
Tie
Price
Prices change throughout the year, but the ARC-X and 1900X are typically close enough that price shouldn’t be your deciding factor.
Instead, buy the collar that best matches how you train.
Which Collar Would I Buy?
I’d choose the Dogtra 1900X if…
- Hunting is your primary focus.
- Your dog runs big.
- You want maximum durability.
- You expect to own one collar for many years.
I’d choose the ARC-X if…
- You train almost every day.
- Your dog wears the collar often.
- Comfort matters.
- You want one collar for family life and hunting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the ARC-X powerful enough for a German Shorthaired Pointer?
Absolutely.
It has more than enough stimulation for nearly every GSP.
Does the 1900X have better range?
No.
Both collars offer approximately ¾-mile range.
Which collar is more comfortable?
The ARC-X.
Its slim receiver is one of its biggest selling points.
Which collar would you buy for hunting?
If hunting is my primary focus, I’d choose the 1900X.
If I’m splitting time between hunting, hiking, and everyday obedience, I’d buy the ARC-X.
Final Verdict
These are two outstanding collars.
You honestly can’t make a bad choice.
Buy the 1900X if:
✅ Hunting comes first.
Buy the ARC-X if:
✅ Everyday comfort is equally important.
For most serious upland hunters, I’d still give the Dogtra 1900X a slight edge.
For the average GSP owner who wants one collar to do everything, the ARC-X is incredibly hard to beat.
Don’t Forget Your Discount
Use coupon code GSP5 to save 5% on qualifying Dogtra orders over $199.
We publish field-tested gear reviews, training guidance, and safety resources specifically for German Shorthaired Pointer owners who hunt, train, and live with their dogs year-round.
